All blogs
    AI Visibility

    How does AI visibility work for home improvement and home services brands?

    5WPR's Home Services Index 2.0 tracked 23 home improvement and home services brands across five AI engines through November 2026. Home Depot and Lowe's dominate the pooled numbers, but the category splits apart once you look at specific product lines.

    Dark blue technical blueprint grid with measurement scales

    Two brands first, then a long tail that only wins by category. 5WPR's Home Services Index 2.0 tracked 23 home improvement and home services brands across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, with its most recent measurement run on November 4, 2026. Home Depot and Lowe's sit within a point of each other at the top of the pooled rankings and lead most of the ten category groups the index tracks. But once the data splits by product line, flooring, paint, design platforms, contractor marketplaces, a different set of specialist brands takes over, and the two big-box leaders barely register as citations from their own websites.

    How was this index actually built?

    5WPR's Home Services Index 2.0 asked 24 questions, 10 written as core category questions and 14 added as neutral follow-ups, three times each across ChatGPT (gpt-5-mini), Claude (claude-sonnet-5-5), Gemini (gemini-3.6-flash) and Perplexity (sonar-pro). That produced 288 planned chat answers, of which 285 were grounded with citations. Separately, the firm ran 41 US desktop searches through Google AI Overviews, which returned an overview on 29 of them, 70.7% of the time, pulled through DataForSEO. Of 360 total planned results across every engine, 329 came back; 31 AI Overview lookups were excluded after repeated attempts. The firm first published the index on June 28, 2026, and last updated it November 7, 2026, with the underlying measurement dated November 4, so this reflects the market as of this week, not a snapshot from earlier in the year.

    Twenty-three brands were tracked across ten separate category groups: big-box home improvement, hardware and specialty retail, tools, flooring, online home goods, paint, contractor and handyman marketplaces, design and remodeling platforms, building materials, and rural property supplies. 5WPR ranks brands only against others in their own category group, not as one combined leaderboard, which matters for reading the results correctly.

    57%of answers named Lowe's, the highest appearance rate tracked
    57%of answers named Home Depot
    25%of answers named Angi, the next closest brand

    Source: 5WPR's Home Services Index 2.0, measured November 4, 2026, linked in the article.

    Which brands actually get named most often?

    Lowe's and Home Depot, by a wide margin, and almost exactly tied. Across all 288 pooled answers, Lowe's was named in 164, a 56.9% appearance rate, and Home Depot in 163, 56.6%. The next closest brand, Angi, trails at 24.7%, with Ace Hardware at 20.5% and Thumbtack at 19.4%. Menards sits at 17.0%, and even Amazon, despite its scale everywhere else online, only reaches 15.3% on home improvement questions specifically.

    That gap between the top two and everyone else holds up inside the individual category groups too. Home Depot and Lowe's tie for the lead in big-box home improvement questions, both appearing in all 36 relevant answers, and both place in the top three for hardware and specialty retail alongside Ace Hardware. Gaming's AI visibility data showed a similarly tight race between Nintendo, PlayStation and Xbox, with 5WPR's report noting no tracked brand differed from another by more than 12 points across engines in that category. The same pattern holds here: this index reports that no tracked brand in the home improvement data varies by more than 12 points between the five engines either, which means the gap between Home Depot and Lowe's is a real, stable finding, not noise from one AI system behaving oddly.

    Does the big-box lead hold in every product category?

    No, and this is the part a brand outside the top two should actually act on. Once the data narrows to a specific product line, different brands win outright. Floor & Decor leads flooring questions, appearing in 34 of 36 answers, ahead of both Lowe's and Home Depot. Wayfair leads online home goods at 24 of 24, ahead of Amazon. Behr and Benjamin Moore are tied at the top of paint questions, both at 24 of 24, ahead of Sherwin-Williams. Houzz owns design and remodeling platform questions at 24 of 24. Angi leads contractor and handyman marketplace questions at 63 of 72, ahead of Thumbtack. Tractor Supply leads rural property supply questions at 12 of 12.

    The lesson in that split is straightforward: a specialist brand does not need to out-mention Home Depot across the whole category to win the visibility that actually matters to its buyers. It needs to dominate the narrower set of questions a customer in its specific niche would actually ask. AI visibility tools built to track this kind of positioning report appearance rate by topic rather than one blended score for exactly this reason, because a blended score would hide every one of the category wins listed above.

    Two of the 23 tracked brands had zero citations to their own domains across the entire sample.

    Why do even the two leading brands barely get cited from their own website?

    Because AI systems are mostly citing what other sites say about Home Depot and Lowe's, not what those two companies say about themselves. Of the 285 grounded chat-engine answers, Lowe's own domains were cited in 68, 23.9%, the highest rate of any tracked brand, and Home Depot followed at 65, 22.8%. Two of the 23 tracked brands had zero own-domain citations across the entire sample. When citations are measured as a share of the total citation pool rather than as an appearance rate, the numbers get even thinner: Home Depot's own domains account for 3.4% of all 2,428 citations recorded, and Lowe's for 3.3%.

    That pattern tracks with what Muck Rack's research on AI citation sources found across industries generally: earned, independently published coverage drives the large majority of what AI systems cite, while a brand's own site drives relatively little of it. In home improvement specifically, the independent layer doing that work is visible in the most-cited domains: lowes.com and homedepot.com lead at 22.5% and 20.0% of citations respectively, but Wikipedia follows close behind at 15.8%, with Reddit at 11.6%, Bob Vila at 11.2%, and Consumer Reports at 9.8%. Customer reviews and comparison sites already carry real weight in how AI systems answer product questions, and this index shows that pattern holding for home improvement retailers as clearly as it does anywhere else.

    What is Google AI Overviews doing differently here?

    Leaning harder on video than the chat engines do. Across the 29 searches that returned an overview, youtube.com was the single most-cited source, appearing in 14 of them, 48.3%, ahead of any retailer's own site. Inside those overviews, Home Depot was named in 16 of 29, 55.2%, and Lowe's in 13 of 29, 44.8%, roughly the same gap seen in the pooled chat-engine data. A brand with a thin or outdated YouTube presence is giving up a citation slot that Google's own AI Overviews is reaching for more readily than a written article.

    What should a home improvement or home services brand actually do with this?

    • Stop benchmarking against the category leaders and start benchmarking against the leader in your specific product line. Floor & Decor, Houzz, Behr and Tractor Supply all outrank Home Depot and Lowe's inside their own niches. That is the more realistic target for a brand that is not a national big-box chain.
    • Treat Wikipedia, Bob Vila and Consumer Reports as citation infrastructure you need covered, not optional extras. Together they outweigh most tracked brands' own-domain citations. How to measure GEO properly means tracking which third-party sources are actually carrying your category's AI answers, then working to be accurately and favorably represented on each one.
    • Build a current YouTube presence if you have not already. Google AI Overviews pulled from YouTube in nearly half of all overviews shown in this category, ahead of any single retailer's own website.
    • Watch for brands the index does not track. 5WPR's report notes untracked names like IKEA, Pottery Barn, HomeAdvisor, Crate & Barrel and Valspar were still mentioned often enough to show up in the raw answer text, a reminder that any fixed brand list in a study like this will miss real competitors worth tracking on your own.

    The direct answer, for anyone who read this far

    Home Depot and Lowe's lead home improvement AI visibility overall, within a point of each other and both cited from their own site in under a quarter of grounded answers. But the category breaks apart by product line: Floor & Decor, Wayfair, Behr, Benjamin Moore, Houzz, Angi and Tractor Supply each lead their own specific niche, which is the realistic place for any brand outside the big two to compete. Wikipedia, Bob Vila, Consumer Reports and YouTube carry more of the citation weight than most brands' own websites do. If you want help figuring out where your brand actually stands in the AI answers your category gets asked, get in touch with our team.

    Written by Womedia Team

    White Ocean Media. Related service: AI Visibility